28. november, 2010 | Dušan Rutar

Veliki anarhistični načrt XII

  • DELICIOUS
  • Google
  • RSS

Velika Freudova lekcija, ki nam jo je zapustil v premislek, ni povezana z razumevanjem psihologije osebnosti vsakega posameznega človeka – še manj je povezana s psihoterapijo, saj je analiza čisto nekaj drugega. Povezana je z nečim, česar se navadno niti ne zavedamo: z načinom, kako ves čas investiramo libido v realnost in jo razumemo, kot da investiranje za nas in naše zaznavanje realnosti ne velja. Sočasno torej delamo oboje: investiramo v realnost in se obnašamo, kot da jo zgolj objektivno opazujemo in opisujemo, kot da imajo probleme z razumevanjem in opisovanjem realnosti zgolj drugi ljudje, ne pa mi sami.

Freudova zapuščina zato ni le resna lekcija, temveč je zlasti velik problem, kajti kako sploh lahko kaj povemo o realnosti, če ne prepoznavamo lastnega vložka, zaradi katerega je vselej drugačna, kot verjamemo? To preprosto pomeni, da smo izgubljeni že čisto na začetku. Prav zaradi tega se moramo v vsakdanjem življenju sprenevedati, da je vse v najlepšem redu.
Začetek je dober in obetaven, kajti prav zaradi njega je na primer možna psihoanaliza. Nekoliko drugače: če ljudje ne bi proizvajali simptomov, analitiki ne bi imeli dela. Freudova zapuščina je zato sočasno navodilo, kako se lotevati razumevanja sveta, in svarilo, naj nikar ne pozabimo, da niti sami nismo imuni pred vsakokratnimi simptomi, ki jih moramo dešifrirati.
Kaj pomeni zapisano v luči tukajšnjih prizadevanj, da bi zgradili boljšo družba, v katero bi bili vključeni tudi invalidi in drugi ljudje s posebnimi potrebami, v luči prizadevanj, ki niso le lokalna, ampak so kar globalna, povezana pa so tudi z razdeljevanjem velikih količin denarja?

Ljudem s posebnimi potrebami seveda ni lahko. V družbi neenakosti in izkoriščanja delovne sile jim je pravzaprav pogosto težko, saj ne morejo dobiti dela, poleg tega pa so tudi predmet političnih špekulacij, postmodernih družbenih projektov, občasnega pomilovanja, pogostega usmiljenja, nenavadnih pogledov in čudnih interpretacij.

Iz tega zornega kota je daleč najbolj pomembna teorija, saj je praksa velikokrat precej vulgarna in nemočna. Pomembna je na primer teorija hendikepa. Ni toliko pomembna empirična invalidnost ljudi, niso toliko pomembne njihove posebne potrebe, zares pomembna je šele razsvetljenska teorija. Zakaj?

Ker je domnevno spoštovanje ljudi s posebnimi potrebami najpogosteje zgolj del obče sprejetih fantazem oziroma imaginarnih scenarijev, v katerih so ljudje s posebnimi potrebami pač posebni, obenem pa so potrebni še pomoči drugih ljudi, ki niso posebni in nimajo posebnih potreb. Ljudje s posebnimi potrebami so danes naši bližnjiki, ker so jih s pomočjo novih medijev spremenili vanje. Nič več niso ubogi družbeni marginalci, sedaj so drugačni in imajo pravico do drugačnosti – kot vsi drugi.

Toda vse to je le površinsko sprenevedanje, ki naj zakrije pogled na vse, kar se dogaja spodaj. Kako bližnje srečanje – na primer med politiki, državnimi uslužbenci in strokovnjaki z ljudmi s posebnimi potrebami – običajno hitro pokaže, da managerji družbenega življenja nimajo pojma o njihovih dejanskih življenjih, o njihovih resničnih potrebah, o tem, kako jih zadovoljevati, da bo ohranjeno človeško dostojanstvo enih in drugih.

V tem je tudi jedro sodobnih razmišljanj o neodvisnem življenju hendikepiranih ljudi. Dokler so posebni, je zanje možno skrbeti in vztrajati v varni razdalji; ko se izkaže, da niso nič posebnega in da imajo natanko take želje in potrebe kot drugi ljudje, zavese padejo, maske se strgajo, nastane suspenz, pojavi se groza, kajti potreba po dostojanstvu človeških eksistenc je univerzalna, empirična realnost velikanskega števila ljudi pa potrjuje spoznanje, da je v kapitalizmu preprosto ni mogoče zadovoljiti.

Noben človek ni namreč nič posebnega, dokler ne začne verjeti v lastne nezavedne fantazme ali pa vanje začnejo verjeti drugi ljudje. Natanko skozi take scenarije se nenadoma pokaže, da se ljudje delijo na posebne in one, ki niso posebni, na te, ki so nekaj več, in one, ki niso nekaj več.

Vsega je konec v trenutku, ko nekdo razkrinka fantazme, ko jih analizira ali dekonstruira, kot bi nemara rekel Derrida, ko torej padejo zavese in sprenevedanje ni več mogoče. V tem je tudi moč vsake analize ali dekonstrukcije. Ki je diskurz in zlasti ne dopušča zastopnikom oblasti, da bi gradili svoje majhne svetove, v katerih skušajo realizirati ali uresničiti lastne nezavedne scenarije o vladanju, podrejanju, nadzorovanju in podobnem, potem pa vse skupaj razširiti še na ves svet, sklicujoč se na globalne trende.

Vse to je kajpak zelo človeško, kot je ves čas opozarjal Freud, celo preveč človeško, kot bi dejal Nietzsche, a prav zato je potrebna neusmiljena kritika fantazmatskih scenarijev in pastoralnih oblastiželjnih povzpetnikov, kajti če jih pustimo pri miru, se nujno spremenijo v človeške monstrume, ki nebrzdano kopičijo oblast, denar in vse drugo.

Teorija hendikepa, katere logično nadaljevanje je Veliki anarhistični načrt, je trn v peti vsakega spodobnega povzpetnika, državnega administratorja in tolstega oblastnika. Če ne bi bila, ne bi bila vredna pol kozarca tople vode. Ne smemo namreč pozabiti, da je ideologija inkluzije oseb s posebnimi potrebami nastala v določenem zgodovinskem obdobju, v katerem je Zahodna civilizacija začela retrogradno ustvarjati mit o srečni in zdravi demokratični družbi (sane society), v kateri živijo vsi ljudje v medsebojni solidarnosti in nežno skrbijo drug za drugega oziroma za vse mogoče posebne potrebe. Mit se je okrepil zlasti v obdobju po drugi svetovni vojni, ko je postalo dokončno jasno, da kapitalizem s prijaznim obrazom prav potrebuje izključevanje ljudi, če sploh hoče preživeti.

Fantazmo o celovitem, organskem, harmoničnem občestvu, v katerega so vključeni vsi ljudje (kot v kaki veliki družini), je kajpak nemogoče realizirati že zaradi tega, ker je fantazma, scenarij torej, ki nastaja kot obrambni manever pred vpogledom v resnično naravo realnosti, ki ni naravna, ampak je umetna, ni zaprta, ampak je odprta in nedoločljiva, ni sklenjena, ampak je nesklenjena. Šele odpoved takim scenarijem ustvari realne možnosti za realizacijo tega, kar se prikazuje skozi mit: odprto družbo, v kateri je na prvem mestu spoštovanje ljudi, ne pa izkoriščanje delovne sile in kopičenje profitov. Onkraj fantazem torej lahko primemo kapitaliste za besedo in se borimo za socializem, kajti dokler bo besednjak o odprtosti, demokraciji, solidarnosti, enakosti in medsebojnem spoštovanju le del imaginarnih scenarijev, ne bo mogoče nikoli preiti od besed k dejanjem, kajti besede so vselej performativne, kar pomeni, da znotraj kapitalizma njihovi uporabniki z njimi vselej že delajo: skrbijo na primer za ohranjanje razmerij moči, ki naj jih prekriva fantaziranje o tem, kako bo ta svet nekega dne dober za vse, kapitalizem pa bo imel prijazen obraz za vsakogar.

Dušan Rutar

 


  • DELICIOUS
  • Google
  • RSS
11 x komentirano
  • Aljo je rekel/-la:

    Ja ja seveda, mogoče, toda kaj ko pospešeno drvimo proti globalnemu fašizmu, ZDA - so zmeraj bolj fašistične, Kitajska je pa fašistična že v svoji osnovi. Predpogoj za spremembe je najprej temeljito čišenje babilonske bratovščine. Socializem ni nikakeršna alternativa koorporacijskemu kapitalizmu, prihodnost je v hologramskih - nepiramidnih sistemih.

  • Aljo je rekel/-la:

    Pa še nekaj, za spremembe bo najprej potrebna 3 industrijska revolucija, predvsem na področju pridobivanja energije. “Nova” fizika bo osnova za spremembe globalnega ekonomsko-političnega modela.

  • Blanka je rekel/-la:

    G. Rutar, vse kolumne ¨Veliki anarhistični načrt od l do XII in …¨, izdajte v knjigi! Škoda bi bilo to samo za Vest!

  • Maja je rekel/-la:

    Nihče ni nič posebnega, oziroma vsi smo nekaj posebnega!

  • Kim je rekel/-la:

    Težko si predstavljam, da kapitalisti sprejmejo socializem!

  • Nenad je rekel/-la:

    Kapitalisti prijazen obraz?

  • binebone je rekel/-la:

    Tole dobr preberite.

    Our Advertisers Represent Some Of The Most Unique Products & Services On Earth!

    STOP DRINKING WATER NOW!

    rense.com

    We’ve Been Had!
    By Jim Kirwan
    11-27-10

    In every war that we’ve publicly known about the American Public was conned into believing that it was always “the right thing and the ONLY thing to do.” Fifty years after the fact when the archives were unsealed we finally discovered in each and every instance the United States lied to the people of this nation-just to have the illegal and unnecessary wars in which hundreds of millions of people died.

    From WWI through WWII, Korea, Vietnam, and the undeclared preemptive strike by GWH Bush in Panama, all the way through the 1991 Iraq War, to the attack on Afghanistan and then back to the war that never really stopped in Iraq, this time under Junior’s diseased oversight. Every single time in each and every one of these “wars” the public was not just misled but we were actively coerced by lies and propaganda to enter into these wars as a requirement of the survival of this nation: Well none of that was ever true!

    In today’s world of massively-invasive technology’s we are not being supposedly threatened from outside the nation; but from WITHIN. We are in the middle of a Holiday Weekend ­ on a Saturday which is the slowest newsday in the whole news-cycle. And today the illegal for-profit corporation (USA INC.), that has created not just this crisis, but every single crisis since 1871 has adopted an entirely new way to attack their target-this time.

    Their target is the American Public. Their method is by use and abuse of all kinds of invasive, illegally used technology, that if IT is not stopped dead, will end our way of life in a long and very ugly disintegration of our way of life.

    That will end any possibility for ordinary people to even live without constant surveillance and continual threats of either being terrorized or of being one of those terrorists ­ there is NO middle-ground ­ as the Bushwhacker said “You’re with us or against us.” This takeover is as potentially masterful in its scope as it is vile in its applications: If this series of new REQUIREMENTS are allowed to go forward-then we can say a permanent GOOD-BYE to everything that was once normal such as going to work on public transportation, going to a sporting event or any kind of conference-not-to-mention any and all political gatherings where any opposition to the guest speakers is now a becoming a felony offense-because there is no longer any free speech in the United States-and there hasn’t been since 1968. Anyone that has tried to “Have their say in public” will attest to this-the rest of the herd only still believes that ‘free-speech’ still exists because they have never tried to use it-in public!

    First of all you should know that we won the battle over scanners at the Airports of this nation over the holiday; TSA blinked, but tomorrow it could resurface unless the public remains determined to end this practice: http://www.brasschecktv.com/page/984.html

    Here’s is some of the “new” information released today: On Saturday, November 27, two days after we kicked the TSA solidly in the ass:

    Body-scanners coming to trains, subways and boats
    ‘ If they do this on commuter trains, buses etc. (they’ve already deputized bus and train operators to “police” passengers on whatever public transportation service they are employed to operate) - they will have succeeded in shutting down transportation for work or pleasure - from coast to coast. No one using those services can expect to ever get where they might be going with any hope of keeping to any kind of schedule - (AMTRACK is already hopelessly off schedule as it is) This will succeed in STRANGLING the scheduling component which is currently working (mostly) to get people to their destinations with a minimum of interruptions: ALL THAT WOULD CHANGE IF THESE criminally-oriented agencies get away with this OUTRAGE - on top of TSA. Welcome to the Début of VIPER!’ http://www.freedomsphoenix.com/News/079240-2010-11-25-body-scanners-
    coming-to-trains-subways-and-boats-homeland-security.htm?From=News

    Then there was this: DHS Wants Behavior Scanners at Sporting Events and Malls:

    ‘They not only “want it” they have already invested millions and perhaps billions to accomplish this. Welcome to the Fourth Reich - If the public “accepts” invasive scanning, and sexual molestations just to fly” then here is chapter two - the COSTS OF THIS OUTRAGE are NOT just PROHIBITIVE- this whole idea represents the final phase in the beginning of the SHUTDOWN OF THE UNITED STATES as ANYTHING OTHER THAN A VIOLENTLY CRIMINAL POLICE STATE - of this there can no longer be any question. This is a video brought to you by “your” HOMELAND SECURITY AGENCY - which is an outrage all by itself!

    Just note how many of the questions being asked here are totally against any and all provisions of the first and fourth amendments to the constitution of the now defunct Constitutional United States - but are in perfect alignment with the DEMANDS being put forward by the PRIVATE FOR PROFIT corporation that lives only inside Washington D.C.!’ http://www.freedomsphoenix.com/News/079234-2010-11-25-dhs-
    wants-behavior-scanners-at-sports-events-malls.htm?From=News

    Then this: Full body scanners popping up at Courthouses nationwide
    ‘Travel is one thing but scanning employees on their way to work, or anyone that is CALLED to visit a government office is a whole other thing. If you don’t show up (OPTING-OUT) then the result could be jail or fines or both. Enough is enough already: These machines must be assembled and publicly destroyed - and everyone associated with their purchase needs to be arrested on suspicion of being complicit in attempting to indite ordinary people for Artificially created SUSPICIONS that are being manufactured each and every hour by INSANE government robots that have NO LEGAL AUTHORITY to do ANY OF WHAT THEY ARE PLANNING TO DO TO INNOCENT PEOPLE!’
    Full-body scanners popping up at courthouses | World News |Axisoflogic.com
    http://axisoflogic.com/artman/publish/Article_61699.shtml

    The amount of radiation that these programs will collectively put into the general population will kill us all very quickly-especially those who will have to undergo this twice every day whenever they try to get to work, as a routine part of life.

    This coupled with everything else that has all been done in SECRET supposedly for reasons of National Security amounts to committing a heinous series of crimes on top of treason against the same people that are paying their salaries while volunteering to be targeted by a falsely created government agency whose sole purpose is to finish destroying whatever might be left of this country.

    Anyone that is not moved to act against this conspiracy, by the privately held for profit corporation that has replaced the long dead Constitutional United States ­ has to be considered legally incompetent ­ because this is clearly a major and massively expensive hustle just to force Americans into surrendering every right we have to the police-state that has been built to segregate, marginalize and imprison the entire population-under the totally false-flag of world-wide terrorism (Which was created by this government from a previously existing agency of the CIA)-immediately after the events of 911 in order to concoct this entirely false situation that now has every American looking at arrest, at possible torture and or imprisonment just for being Americans!

    I don’t know about you but I absolutely hate to be conned-especially when the con has been going on since 1871, which is one hundred and thirty-nine years!
    Damnit people will you not take the time to DO SOMETHING about this-This time!?

    kirwanstudios@sbcglobal.net

  • Boris_j je rekel/-la:

    “Dokler so posebni, je zanje možno skrbeti in vztrajati v varni razdalji; ko se izkaže, da niso nič posebnega in da imajo natanko take želje in potrebe kot drugi ljudje, zavese padejo, maske se strgajo, nastane suspenz, pojavi se groza,…”

    Tukaj je smiselno dodati intervju z Andrejem Jugom in Mladine: http://www.mladina.si/tednik/200516/clanek/nar–hendikep-max_modic/, ki je že pred časom izpostavil kakšen tabu je spolnost hendikepiranih oseb. Kaj drugega pa je spolnost kot tisto področje kjer smo si na neki ravni vsi enaki in nič posebnega, oziroma kot je rekel Andrej Jug: “”Širši javnosti bi morali preko medijev približati dejstvo, da smo hendikepirani tudi spolna bitja, ki sicer ne fukamo, bi pa zelo radi, če nas po tej liniji ne bi zatirali ali zavračali.” In pojavi se groza…

  • Forestina je rekel/-la:

    Biometrična massmatrika ni več le teorija zarote.

    Bennis o cablegate :)

    http://www.therealnews.com/t2/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=31&Itemid=74&jumival=5939

    Phyllis Bennis: Clinton ordered spying on UN leaders shows Bush style still around

  • Kooperativc je rekel/-la:

    Počasi vsi postajamo ljudje s posebnimi potrebami. Dejstvo pa je, da hitreje kot tečemo, da bi se rešili iz tega hendikepa, globlje tonemo (v povprečju seveda). Na nas (hendikepirancih - navadnih ljudeh) se služijo enormni denarji medtem, ko davkoplačevalci (mi navadni ljudje oz. hendikepiranci) vedno težje to plačujemo. Zato je solidarnost in (samo)omejevanje prevelike neenakosti v družbi nujno potrebna in v interesu vseh.

    Kooperativa je alternativa ;)